Skip to content

 

1990s Best Picture Oscar Winners Ranked From Worst To Best

23 February 2017 | Features, Film Lists | by Andreas Babiolakis

This is the sixth examination of every Academy Award for Best Picture winner. Sadly, the Oscar Bait years continue, and you will find the majority of the worst offenders of this phenomenon within these ten years. Epics weren’t as epic as they may have seemed, and some of the experiments here fall as flat as a floorboard.

However, the ‘90s also featured great achievements that include the mighty revival of the Western genre, the epic films that did contain merit (and weren’t just hollow pictures meant to win awards), and even a film that defied every Oscar regulation (it was released early in the year, was a disturbing film and did very little to up its chances despite its many wins).

We have almost reached the newest winners, but let us reminisce to the last nostalgic era. Here are the Best Picture winners of the ‘90s ranked from worst to best.

 

10. Braveheart (1995)

Braveheart

William Wallace famously screams for freedom, yet one of Braveheart’s biggest issues is how forceful the entirety of its length feels. Mel Gibson’s control on a variety of elements here warrants some sort of praise.

Gibson did try his best to deliver something noteworthy, and it is clearly evident. The occasional special effect still stands strong, and the rest did not age well at all (but the attempts are still admirable). Outside of the stunts and effects, Braveheart is a strenuous test of patience, time and care.

From the immature flashing of genitalia, to the frigid dialogue, Braveheart is borderline phonographic. It is juvenile, shallow, and just downright irritating. If viewing many well choreographed battle sequences (let’s be honest, here) is your primary focus, then Braveheart will not upset you in the slightest.

Otherwise, over twenty years later, it may be virtually impossible to not be angered by this macho film. It claims to tell an important story, and yet gets the majority of its facts wrong (inauthenticity can be okay if it fits a better story, but this many instances is inexcusable, especially if the film is still awful).

It tries to take you to a different time period, yet it really feels like a series of people from the nineties in costumes. Braveheart is as artificial as it gets, and the few cases of remarkable effects will do nothing to change this one.

 

9. Forrest Gump (1994)

Forrest Gump

Why not Pulp Fiction? Well, Pulp Fiction was as big of a staple of the ‘90s as this curious tale was, yet something about Forrest Gump continues to stay with fans even to this day. If you sit down and really evaluate Forrest Gump, it is one of the more mismatched Best Picture winners to win the award.

There are parts that are masterful and dreadful throughout, and it is quite peculiar as to how a film can do so much right and so much wrong. Moments like the revelations of the many historical happenings that Gump influenced can be funny or ludicrous (Seriously? He is linked to the Klu Klux Klan?), then you have the actual plot points that make absurdist sense (the guy ran for years? Why?). Basically, Forrest Gump is at times a complete joke.

Then there are the touching moments that are not just well done, they’re borderline genius. The moment when we realize that Gump knew he was different (when he asks if his son suffers from the same disorders he does) is a stunning revelation.

Gump’s lack of understanding of the world and his complete wisdom on love and human connectivity is sweet. The sentimentality, intertwined with Robert Zemeckis’ usual exploration of cinematic innovation, has made Forrest Gump a fan favourite despite its flaws, as if the film was a movie representation of its titular character: problematic, yet sincere.

 

8. The English Patient (1996)

Anyone who watches Seinfeld will remember Elaine Benes’ absolute distaste for Anthony Minghella’s romantic epic. Everyone shuns her for hating this film, and while it is funny and a bit of a hyperbole, there is some actual truth to the mass hysteria that surrounded The English Patient.

Was it really as good as everyone said? The sets are lovely and the aesthetics are powerful, but how much could truly be taken away from this movie? How memorable was the plot, aside from the fact that a complex love exists that results in a need to murder out of jealousy?

The main issue is that we get the crux of this film from Ralph Fiennes’ character, and what we don’t hear from him, we witness from an unrelated romance between Juliette Binoche’s and Naveen Andrews’ characters.

Otherwise, The English Patient is a tender cinematic experience, cloaked in sepia tones, whispered performances and tip-toed care. It isn’t nearly as bad as Elaine Benes has said, and while it is still an overrated winner, there is still something tangible about The English Patient.

 

7. Shakespeare in Love (1998)

shakespeare-in-love

This period piece romantic comedy is by far one of the weirdest Best Picture winners to date. This is not because it beat Saving Private Ryan, although that does play partially into the absurdity of the situation.

John Madden’s fictitious take on Shakespeare experiencing a drought of creativity makes very little sense realistically (this story does not even remotely connect to any particular moment of his life in all seriousness), but at the same time the web of lies fed to us do not seem all too improbable. Could Shakespeare find a muse who would stage herself as a young boy to take part in his plays? Supposedly, yes.

Shakespeare in Love, while not resembling the writing of the master it is based off of (of course not), is strung together with some witty dialogue and well crafted comedy. With a few hiccups here and there (seriously, that child who gives away so many plot elements is unbearable), this is not a perfect experiment.

However, it is still an experiment, and the risks are something to truly take account of. It even, puzzlingly, won Best Picture, and it perplexes many to this day. It gets a bad wrap for being one of the worst Best Picture winners, but that is a claim that is undeserved, no matter how weird this all is.

 

6. Dances With Wolves (1990)

Dances-With-Wolves-Kevin-Costner

Try your best to forget that Goodfellas was snubbed for this Best Picture win, and it may make your viewing of Dances with Wolves a lot better. There is a slow start that feels like a typical ‘80s/‘90s Western, when the snubbing’s backlash feels particularly strong.

Once John Dunbar settles on his own and begins to live with the wild, that is when this Western revival picks up steam. Then you have the integration with the Sioux tribe to really stir the intentions of the film around with every character soon to clash with one another.

The plot may seem old hat by now, especially with many iterations having been made since then (the most infamous case is Avatar), and while it was not the most original idea back in 1990, Dances with Wolves was less of a comparison basis for these story blueprints before.

So it shouldn’t be, with its large landscapes and heartfelt directing used to set the score here. Sure, these similar films also explore settings and characters, but Costner’s take feels especially attributed to the contexts here. Dances With Wolves is without question an Oscar bait film, but that label does not always mean that it has to be bad.

 

 

Pages: 1 2


   

Other Brilliant Movie Posts On The Web
   

Like Our Facebook Page and Get Daily Updates
   
  • colonelkurtz

    Anyone else getting tired of these Oscar somethings worst to best?

    • Gilbert Hays

      Well they’re only doin’ ’em for best pictures per decade, so there’s only one or two lists like this left, and then they’re done.

      • vasilis4

        excellent comment!!

    • Abhishek

      Yeah. They are re posting them. Even though I agree that their fresh articles have been related to Oscars lately and just for the sake of them to stop I hope Oscar gets over sooner.

    • zak1

      I do appreciate that these lists are carefully thought out, but having a new one every day does sort of overwhelm the concept – I think they would have done better to space them apart on a weekly basis. It gives people time to digest each decade. If it were spread out more, then I’d actually like to see earlier decades like the 30s considered as well.

      • colonelkurtz

        That does make sense, though personally I care less about lists I can find on Wikipedia–I’d much rather read someone’s personal list of 1990s best films. More controversial sometimes and not necessarily better, but I might learn of a new interesting film that way, whereas these Oscar lists just tell me films I already knew were popular/good were considered popular/good.

        • zak1

          I think the films on such personal lists are very often much better than the award winners – it’s interesting that when I saw the topic was the 1990s, I got excited because so many amazing films came out during that period – but then the list proved an anticlimactic reminder that few of those adventurous projects I’d envisioned were even nominated, and none of them made it to the list of actual Best Picture winners.

          What makes a work great is often the kind of risk taking that upsets establishment sensibilities like the Academy’s. Maybe that’s why it’s called “pushing the envelope”

          It was good to see something like The Piano get all that awards attention, but could you imagine seeing Harvey Keitel get nominated for Bad Lieutenant? Look at how Do the Right Thing got frozen out (a 90s film in all other respects that wound up getting released in 1989, just like Titanic is a 00s film in spirit that happened to get released in the 90s)

          But, given that this list set its parameters at Oscar Winners Only, I thought it did a decent job.

  • AmazingAmy

    Dude, SIL and DWTW should ranked last….cant believe its won over SPR and Goodfellas

  • 1. Unforgiven
    2. Schindler’s List
    3. Silence of the Lambs
    4. Titanic
    5. Forrest Gump
    6. Braveheart
    7. American Beauty
    8. The English Patient
    9. Dances with Wolves
    10. Shakespeare in Love

    With the exception of the top 4 films in the list as they’re great films while I also have a soft spot for both Forrest Gump and Braveheart. American Beauty is overrated as there’s so many other films from 1999 that are so much better. The English Patient is good but over Fargo and Breaking the Waves? Dances with Wolves…. boring! Shakespeare in Love…. lame! The Thin Red Line or Saving Private Ryan should’ve won.

    • Stephus

      I like your order much more and agree with it but I think Dances With Wolves is the worst. I’d switch with Shakespeare in Love.

      • OK, I’m cool with that. It’s just hard to choose between both of those films since they’re both so boring.

        • Stephus

          Lol true

    • Unforgiven is borderline perfection.
      I’m torn on American Beauty. Loved it in ’99, but 8-10 years later I thought it aged horribly (think: Ordinary People from the 80s). Rewatched it last year and really dug it.

      • Actually, I think Ordinary People has gotten better with age as I think it’s gotten an unfair rap just because it beat Raging Bull.

        • I mean, it’s a fine movie, but certainly far from “great.”

    • Mortimer

      I’d replace Titanic with American Beauty on your list. Some of Titanic dialogue is really cringe-worthy. And there are some unbelievable, ridiculous scenes too.

      • I will agree with you that some of the dialogue in Titanic as well as some of the scenes in the film were ridiculous but it’s still an amazing film. I wish James Cameron made some changes such the fact that there was enough room for Jack and Rose on that little raft. All Jack had to do was be on top of her.

        • Mortimer

          She was a little bit fat though. They would went straight to the bottom of Atlantic 🙂

          • No, no, no, no, no…. there was a way they could’ve both survived and stay warm. He could’ve put his dick up her ass and in the traditional position while they would use their arms as paddle to get a whistle and be saved. The only problem is that he’s stuck to her and then they would have to use some hot water and that is how they conceived their first child.

          • Mortimer

            Lol, that’s a good one !

  • Stephus

    1. Unforgiven
    2. Schindler’s List
    3. Silence of the Lambs
    4. American Beauty
    5. Titanic
    6. Forrest Gump
    7. Braveheart
    8. The English Patient
    9. Shakespeare In Love
    10. Dances With Wolves

  • Abhishek

    I think American beauty was boring and The sixth sense was a masterpiece which should have definitely won. I do not get the logic of Academy always ignoring Psychological horror genres as in they could be nominated but they would never win! And inspire of stupid dances with wolves, Goodfellas should have won is needless to say!

  • Like I did for the 80’s list, here’s my picks for best movies year-by-year, unlike the 80’s list this one has changed pretty much the same through the years.

    1990 – Miller’s Crossing
    1991 – Terminator 2
    1992 – Unforgiven
    1993 – Schindler’s List
    1994 – Pulp Fiction
    1995 – Heat
    1996 – Fargo
    1997 – Good Will Hunting
    1998 – Saving Private Ryan (but wanna say Lebowski)
    1999 – Matrix (it holds up)

    • Ted Wolf

      maybe, I love the self-importance and pageantry of the whole thing. I’ve been watching them since I was a little kid in the late 1960’s. I’m not stopping now.

  • Zwei

    American Beauty such a shitty movie

  • skainstein

    I’ve two lists.
    This first list is of the nominees who sould have won.
    1 – Braveheart
    2 – Life Is Beautiful
    3 – The Shawshank Redemption
    4 – Schindler’s List
    5 – The Green Mile
    6 – Unforgiven
    7 – Fargo
    8 – The Silence of the Lambs
    9 – Awakenings
    10 – Titanic (It’s lame… but i liked it)

    The second list is of the movies who sould have won (nominees or not).
    1 – American History X
    2 – Braveheart
    3 – The Shawshank Redemption
    4 – Schindler’s List
    5 – Matrix
    6 – Unforgiven
    7 – Trainspotting
    8 – The Silence of the Lambs
    9 – Edward Scissorhands
    10 – L.A. Confidential

    • elhenzo

      Ummm, LA Confidential was nominated.

  • The fuck is Unforgiven doing so high on the list?