Skip to content


The 10 Most Underrated Actors Working Today

19 August 2016 | Features, People Lists | by Caio Coletti

5. Chris Pine

Chris Pine

Another looker that rarely gets more substantial roles because Hollywood mostly sees him as a shallow leading man, Chris Pine has a lot of potential and should be better cast by Hollywood.

He even did a scathing satire of his own status as a romantic/adventure lead in Into the Woods, and ended up being one of the funniest, most interesting parts of the film (and he’s got some pipes on him too!). Another example of his comedic timing is his hilarious role in the Netflix miniseries Wet Hot American Summer: First Day of Camp.

It’s not only his comedic persona that’s compelling, though – he’s brilliant in Craig Zobel’s apocalyptic recreation of the tale of Adam, Eve and the Serpent (playing the figurative serpent, by the way) Z for Zachariah; did a great job in a more complex role in The Finest Hours; and most recently took on the most complicated and interesting role of his career in David Mackenzie’s brilliant Hell or High Water. Expect great things from this guy.


4. Ryan Reynolds


This Canadian star may be getting his due now with the not-that-surprising success of Deadpool, but he has been largely underserved of good roles in his career in Hollywood.

From rom-com lead to action star, American cinema never quite grasped what to do with Reynolds’ explosive charisma, the extra layer of depth he brings to his roles, or the tremendous work he tends to do when he finds a character that can flex both those muscles.

That’s exactly what happens in both 2010’s Buried and 2015’s Mississippi Grind. The former relays on his charisma to carry a film almost completely by himself, while also asking him to build a complete and compelling character with the few details it provides; meanwhile, the latter casts him as a charming scammer with a streak of good luck, who becomes somewhat of a mentor to an older, less lucky guy, but who also has a lot of issues to work through. Give him a part like that, and Reynolds will knock it out of the park – it’s just a matter of knowing how to use him.


3. Casey Affleck

Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford

The younger brother of Oscar-winner Ben Affleck should by all means be an Oscar winner himself, exactly for the film that brought him his one and only nod, western The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford.

Unnerving and unforgettable in a role that asked for both those qualities, Casey tends to be typecast as uptight, slightly-off guys, or outright nasty fellas, and then work his way out of that box himself. Just look at what he does in The Finest Hours and especially Ain’t Them Bodies Saints.

Casey’s a striking performer who deserves better, more complex roles. Give him a really big, really fascinating role, and he’ll be the best thing onscreen – it’s what seems to happen in Kenneth Lonergan’s outstanding Manchester by the Sea, so maybe there’s a reckoning coming for the younger Affleck brother. If so, it would be more than well deserved.


2. Maggie Gyllenhhaal


Another younger sibling who ended up in the shadow of her brother’s success, Maggie Gyllenhaal is such a fantastic actress it’s hard to fathom why Hollywood didn’t take better advantage of her talents by now.

Her Emmy-nominated, Golden Globe-winning turn in the BBC miniseries The Honourable Woman aside, she was absolutely unbelievable in two difficult and very different roles: 2002’s dark comedy Secretary and 2006’s indie drama Sherrybaby.

And let’s not even talk about her Oscar-nominated performance in Crazy Heart, lending soulfulness to a film that’s definitely not lacking on that. She does the same for 2006’s Stranger Than Fiction, starring opposite Will Ferrell, and Hysteria, a charming little rom-com about the advent of the vibrator (seriously). Just wait for her turn alongside James Franco in porn industry drama The Deuce – surely another brilliant effort in a terrific career.


1. Ben Foster

Ben Foster

Another one of those surprisingly veteran actors at the age of 35, Ben Foster has been around since 1996, and achieved a speck of fame pretty early on too, after his guest turn in Six Feet Under and big-screen roles in X-Men: The Last Stand and Alpha Dog.

Such beginnings would not betray the kind of actor he would become, however, always taking interesting parts in decent to brilliant movies, turning up the heat when it was needed (see 3:10 to Yuma) and playing it understated when it wasn’t (Ain’t Them Bodies Saints).

Foster really is a jack-of-all-trades, but he’s definitely not a master of none. He just can do both really, amazingly, well – and sometime even mix the two styles when a role like Sergeant Will Montgomery in The Messenger comes along.

There’s something vibrant and intense about him, but Foster never really lets it out, playing along with the film’s “macho drama” and its hidden emotional depth in a ticking-time-bomb performance for the ages. He’ll kill it again this year in David Mackenzie’s Hell or High Water, alongside fellow actor on our list Chris Pine.

Author Bio: Caio Coletti is a Brazilian-born journalist, a proud poptimist, and has too many opinions to keep them all to himself.



Pages: 1 2


Other Brilliant Movie Posts On The Web

Like Our Facebook Page and Get Daily Updates
  • Dimitri Poenaru

    Totally agree on most of them, especially Chris Evans and Maggie Gyllenhaal. But for me, Casey Affleck lacks acting talent.

  • Isdal

    Waiting for someone to mention the lack of Sam Rockwell on this list

  • jann1k

    Tobey Kebbell, sadly he was cast in some pretty bad movies, but otherwise he’s a brilliant actor. Totally agree with Ben Foster though! Loved him in the highly underrated Pandorum and even his performance in the mediocre 30 Days of Night was a creepy standout!

    • Cassandra Atticum

      Toby Kebbell was sooo creepy in The Escape Artist!

      • jann1k


  • Tiago Nunes

    Kirsten Dunst definitely.

  • Μεγαλοαστός

    Paul Giamatti

  • Rudi

    I can’t agree more concerning Casey Affleck. He’s been my favourite actor for years now and he still is. I could listen to that unique voice for days in a row.

    And to nominate one for your next list: Emma Roberts. You see her growing from role to role and now with Nerve she’s finally shown she can carry a movie on her own.

    • Bobby Calloway

      She’s excellent in Scream Queens. She plays a bitch to such perfection that she’s incredible to watch.

  • Special_One

    Where do ToC find their writers? When you write like a four year old, and judge how “underrated” actors are with the credibility of a fourteen year old girl who’s just seen a guy take off his shirt for the first time, there’s no way you get to write for a supposedly serious site. Unless that site is ToC, apparently. You know what, I’m actually done. I’m not reading ToC anymore. It’s been going downhill for a while now, and the fact that Caio Coletti still writes for this site just proves that they don’t give a shit.

  • Yudha Wirawanda

    no Jake Gyllenhaal? Kirsten Dunst? Ben Mendelshon, Mads Mikkelsen…an the writer chose Taissa Varmiga instead smh

  • Yudha Wirawanda

    Jake Gyllenhaal, Kirsten Dunst, Ben Mendelshon, Dane Deehan, Mads Mikkelsen, Ben Whishaw, Guy Pearce, Michael Shannon, Paul Bettany, even Robert Pattinson

    • Mortimer

      Ben Mendelsohn is excellent actor. So underrated. Waiting to see him and Rooney Mara in UNA this year.

  • Bobby Calloway

    I find Blake Lively to be incredibly underrated. Although she’s a beautiful lady, she doesn’t just do roles that showcase her beauty. She’s gone against type for The Town and Hick – playing trashy addicts – and she really delivered some great work in The Age of Adaline. She was able to carry The Shallows almost entirely on her own too.

  • Sreejith

    ‘Another younger sibling who ended up in the shadow of her brother’s success
    ‘– Maggie is the elder one, not Jake

  • Cassandra Atticum

    David Tennant, Sam Rockwell, Ben Mendelsohn, Christopher Berry, Olivia Colman, Eva Green

  • Ricardo Correia

    Hal Holbrook, at 92 is still working and proving why he is one of the best of his generation